Op-ed in San Jose Merc: Stem Cell Agency a Bust

The headline on the op-ed article in the San Jose Mercury News read "Old Boss or New Boss, state stem cell agency still a bust."

The piece by K. Lloyd Billingsley, editorial director of the Pacific Research Institute, a conservative think tank in San Francisco, said,

"...Californians do not get what they pay for....CIRM's own scientists acknowledge that no CIRM-produced cures have trickled down to California patients."

Billingsley also focused on salaries at CIRM, including that of the new chairman, CIRM President Alan Trounson and co-vice chairman Art Torres.

Billingsley additionally quoted this writer as saying,

"Voters' expectations are certainly an important measure in assessing the stem-cell agency. At this point, I suspect most voters would not say that their expectations have been fulfilled."

The piece generated extremely modest reader reaction. It included one comment from stem cell scientist Paul Knoepfler of UC Davis. He said,

"I think this opinion piece is a bust. It is full of misleading information and bends everything to fit the extreme agenda beneath the surface. CIRM has done an enormous amount of good and as a stem cell scientist I am confident that new treatments and cures will be created via CIRM." 

Billingsley's piece appeared online July 17.