Sacramento Bee Whacks Pay Plan for New CIRM Chair

In case you missed it, The Sacramento Bee editorialized last week about the $3 billion California stem cell agency, deploring its much-criticized, dual-CEO structure and the possibility of a $400,000 salary for a new, part-time chairman.

The March 28 editorial also caught the eye of Wesley J. Smith, a bioethicist who doesn't have much truck with the state's stem cell research program. He wrote on his blog,

"It isn’t the management structure that is so wrong about the CIRM.  It is the whole cronyism/conflicts of interest/arrogant thing.  California can’t afford the CIRM’s borrow and spend mandate when our infrastructure is collapsing and our state sinking to the bottom of a red ink Marianas Trench."

The Bee's editorial pointed to the proposal (first reported on the California Stem Cell Report March 23) by outgoing CIRM Chairman Robert Klein, a real estate investment banker, Art Torres, co-vice chairman of the CIRM and former state legislator, and Ted Love, a biotech industry executive and vice chair of CIRM's Evaluation Subcommittee, to use "private" donor funds to pay a portion of the new chairman's salary. The Bee said,

"Nonsense. It’s all public money. That board does not need a part-time chair with that kind of salary. The board should nix it at the next meeting. Having a single agency with two CEO-level salaries is craziness at any time, but especially during a deep economic downturn. The Legislature should realign the roles of board chair and agency president before this goes too far. Make it crystal clear that the full-time president manages all day-to-day operations – and that the board chair is a part-time oversight role."

The good news for CIRM in the editorial is that it drew only nine comments from readers on The Bee's Web site. All were negative about CIRM, however.

(Editor's note: an earlier version of this item incorrectly said that Ted Love was chair of the Evaluation Subcommittee.)

Half-Million Salary for Klein?

SAN FRANCISCO -- Back in the early days of the California stem cell research effort, its newly elected chairman – millionaire real estate investment banker Robert Klein -- said he would not accept a salary for his work.

Now that is changing. He could be drawing a salary as high as $508,750, perhaps as early as this year. But the money may not come from state coffers.

The question of salaries for both the chairman of CIRM and the vice chairman came up during Thursday's hearing on the agency's budget for 2008-09.

John M. Simpson, stem cell project director for the Consumer Watchdog group of Santa Monica, Ca., asked whether the budget included salaries for the chairman and the vice chair.

The answer was no. But Klein, who has held his post since December 2005, said, "It's true at some point this issue needs to be addressed."

He said that personally he would like to see "non-taxpayer dollars" used for salaries for the chairman and vice chairman rather than using funds that could be used for research. He indicated that he would not be averse to raising private funds for salary purposes.

The vice chairman of CIRM is Ed Penhoet, also a multimillionaire. He does not accept a salary. We are querying him on his position on salaries.