Thursday, March 22, 2007

More on Plagiarism, Prayer and Cha

Patent attorney Lawrence Ebert has posted details concerning Kwang-Yul Cha, whose subsidiary has won a $2.6 million California stem cell grant, and Cha's "anonymous prayer" paper in The Journal of Reproductive Medicine.

Writing on his Ipbiz site, Ebert said:
"One co-author is a convicted felon, one co-author has had his name removed, but JRM won't retract it."
Ebert also had more details on the plagiarism issue from The Scientist magazine.

"Fertility and Sterility has censured the authors(including Cha) of a 2005 article after learning a Korean journal had published the identical paper one year earlier. The Fertility and Sterility authors also left off the name of Jeong-Hwan Kim, who was listed as the first author on the Korean paper and performed the bulk of the research reported in both papers."
The Scientist piece continued:
"The journal will also issue a note in an upcoming issue describing the transgression, and has barred every author listed on the original Fertility and Sterility paper from contributing papers to the journal for three years, editor Alan DeCherney told The Scientist. 'This is a serious punishment.'"
Sphere: Related Content

1 comment:

  1. Anonymous12:48 AM

    The FS case is also involved in a patent right issue. Kwang Yul CHA and Sook Hwan LEE had applied for a patent of the idea just one day after Kim left the country. Now the patent is owned by CHA group itself.

    The funny thing is the document used for the application is not even the FS article but the exact copy of the Korean article in which Kim was the first author.

    ReplyDelete